Episode 6: We're Gonna Need a Bigger BoatEdit
Premiere: January 12, 2011 The chefs go fishing for their ingredients and serve up the catch of the day at an end of summer beach party.
- Elimination Challenge: In a double elimination, the remaining culinary all-stars hook and cook a fish dish in Montauk and at the Water Taxi Beach in Long Island City for a summer's-end beach party.
- Team 1: Antonia, Jamie, and Tiffani
- Team 2: Carla, Dale T., and Tre
- Team 3: Angelo, Michael, and Tiffany
- Team 4: Fabio, Marcel, and Richard
- WINNER: Carla (Smoked Blue Fish Lettuce Wrap, Pickled Watermelon Rind, Radishes, Bagel Croutons). She wins a trip to Amsterdam and $5000 for airfare.
- ELIMINATED: Jamie (Striped Bass, Watermelon Salad with Fresh Dill, Shaved Radishes and Cucumber Water) and Tiffani (Smoked Blue Fish with Tomato, Roasted Corn and Zucchini Ribbon Salad)
- Guest Judge: Kerry Heffernan (Elimination Challenge)